Research Myth 11: Ability Grouping

John DabellI trained as a primary school teacher 25 years ago, starting my career in London and then I taught in a range of schools in the Midlands. In between teaching jobs, I worked as an Ofsted inspector (no hate mail please!), national in-service provider, project… Read more about John DabellWhy do we bother with ability grouping?Policy makers have repeatedly supported the practice and many parents back it, yet research regularly tells us that ability grouping has no academic benefits and there is a severe negative impact for students in the lowest groups.Professor Rob Coe and colleagues at Durham University published ‘What makes great teaching?’The research warns that many common practices can be harmful to learning and have no grounding in research including grouping students by ability. They note: “Evidence on the effects of grouping by ability, either by allocating students to different classes, or to within-class groups, suggests that it makes very little difference to learning outcomes” (Higgins et al, 2014).Described as a zero-sum game, watch the Toolkit Talk video from the EEF’s website and see John Hattie’s highly pertinent comments in relation to equity.Saiying Steenbergen-Hu et al (2017) have recently scrutinised thousands of studies and the results of almost 100 years of research on the effects of ability grouping and acceleration. They found  evidence of academic benefits of within-class grouping, cross-year grouping by subject, and grouping for the gifted, but didn’t find any benefit of between-class grouping and the results were consistent regardless of whether pupils were high-, medium-, or low-achievers.The whole-class approach of maths mastery programmes has now started to a shift in thinking about ability groups. As Pete Boyd and Andy Ash (2017) have found, setting is in tension with the beliefs of a mastery approach and teachers are beginning to move away from ability groups as it is the old-way of doing things.Mastery has made setting irrelevant. For a real insight into the politics of setting see Tim Dracup’s incredible blog. Ability groups is rubbish if you are in the bottom group.Verdict:Related

Read Previous

Do Children Sit Too Many Standardised Tests?

Read Next

Is Middle Leadership For You?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *